Seneca Lake Farms was established sometime between 1947 and 1950 by The Arthur Crane Company. Previously, Seneca Lake existed as a small pond known as McMickle’s Pond.
In 1989, The Crane Company decided to sell the lake to its members. Several payment plans were offered to suit everyone’s needs. The payment plans were successfully managed and the lake now had community ownership. However, a short 11 years later, the community would lose its beloved lake to a tremendous storm.
On August 12, 2000, a storm dumped 14+ inches of rainfall on the area. Water levels began to rise and about 6PM that evening, the lake had topped its earthen dam. The weight of the water was too much and the dam gave way draining the entire lake in less than 15 minutes, turning Seneca Lake into a mud field.
After the storm and subsequent dam failure, Seneca Lake would remain empty for 4 years turning the site into a meadow. In 2004, the dam was rebuilt and the lake was allowed to refill.
Situated on Seneca Lake’s east shore, the commercial property initially started as a Grange Hall and eventually became the local tavern. It is believed to start as Happy Mac’s Tavern, owned by Jack and Annie McEllen. Jack was a local radio personality in Newton. “Monk” and Milli McCarrick then purchased the restaurant and kept the name.
The tavern then changed owners again as Pat and Al Blanchard purchased the property and the tavern became known as PATAL. As owners came and went, so did the name. The Galley, Sophisticated Otter, and most recently Zoes By The Lake were some of the names of the local tavern. Unfortunately, the property currently sits vacant on the auction block awaiting a new owner and name.